MedicareFAQ
NJ
Updated November 2026

Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Plans in New Jersey

Understand your coverage choices, compare costs, and learn when you can enroll or switch Medigap policies in New Jersey.

Talk to an Agent

Medigap helps pay some of the deductibles, coinsurance, and copayments left by Original Medicare. Choosing a policy means comparing both benefits and the rules that determine when an insurer must accept your application.

This guide walks through New Jersey’s enrollment protections and practical shopping steps, alongside the existing carrier comparisons. Medigap is different from Medicare Advantage and does not include prescription coverage in policies sold today.

Who Can Buy Medigap in New Jersey?

Medicare Supplement insurance works alongside Original Medicare. You generally need both Part A and Part B, and you pay a separate Medigap premium in addition to your Medicare premiums. Each policy covers one person, so spouses choose their own coverage.

Your federal Medigap Open Enrollment Period lasts six months. It begins the first month you are 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. During this window, insurers cannot use your health to deny a policy they sell or charge more. If you delay Part B while working, this window may begin after your 65th birthday. Read Medicare’s enrollment guidance before choosing a start date.

If you qualify for Medicare before age 65

New Jersey has separate protections for people eligible through disability. For those first eligible on or after January 1, 2020, the state describes a 12-month application window after Part B enrollment for designated Plan D coverage. Under age 50, coverage is through the state’s contracted carrier, currently Horizon; ages 50–64 have a different carrier-offer requirement. Premium protections tie these designated policies to the same carrier’s age-65 rate.

These rules do not mean every plan letter is guaranteed to everyone under 65. Earlier eligibility dates have different Plan C provisions. Check the NJ Department of Banking and Insurance requirements for your age and eligibility date.

How to Compare New Jersey Medigap Plans

Start with the coverage you need, then compare insurers selling that plan letter. Standardized benefits are the same for the same letter, but premiums, discounts, service, and rate histories can differ.

  1. Check your enrollment protections. Confirm whether you are in open enrollment or have a guaranteed issue right before relying on a quote.
  2. Choose your benefits. Compare Plan G’s excess-charge coverage with Plan N’s potential office and emergency-room copays. Neither pays the Part B deductible.
  3. Request comparable quotes. Use the same ZIP code, start date, plan letter, and personal details. Ask which discounts are included and when they can end.
  4. Evaluate the insurer. Review financial strength, complaint information, service, and past increases. Past prices do not guarantee future rates.

Compare your total budget, including Part B, prescription drug coverage, and expenses Medigap does not cover. A lower monthly premium can come with more costs when you receive care.

Compare Medicare Supplement Carriers in New Jersey

Use these carriers as a starting point for comparing policies. Availability and underwriting vary. Request a current quote rather than relying on a statewide starting price.

Compare coverage and costs

AARP / UnitedHealthcare

Plan G

Request a quote

Plan N

Request a quote

Availability

Confirm by ZIP

Ask for current plan availability, premiums, discounts, and underwriting requirements for your ZIP code. Compare the same plan letter and effective date across insurers.

(888) 335-8996
Compare coverage and costs

Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of NJ

Plan G

Request a quote

Plan N

Request a quote

Availability

Confirm by ZIP

Ask for current plan availability, premiums, discounts, and underwriting requirements for your ZIP code. Compare the same plan letter and effective date across insurers.

(888) 335-8996
Compare coverage and costs

Mutual of Omaha

Plan G

Request a quote

Plan N

Request a quote

Availability

Confirm by ZIP

Ask for current plan availability, premiums, discounts, and underwriting requirements for your ZIP code. Compare the same plan letter and effective date across insurers.

(888) 335-8996
Compare coverage and costs

Aetna

Plan G

Request a quote

Plan N

Request a quote

Availability

Confirm by ZIP

Ask for current plan availability, premiums, discounts, and underwriting requirements for your ZIP code. Compare the same plan letter and effective date across insurers.

(888) 335-8996
Compare coverage and costs

Cigna

Plan G

Request a quote

Plan N

Request a quote

Availability

Confirm by ZIP

Ask for current plan availability, premiums, discounts, and underwriting requirements for your ZIP code. Compare the same plan letter and effective date across insurers.

(888) 335-8996

Medicare Supplement Prices in New Jersey

Premiums depend on the applicant, policy, location, effective date, and discounts. Compare personalized quotes using the same details for each insurer.

Insurance CompanyPlan G MonthlyPlan N MonthlyPlan F Monthly
CignaRequest a quoteRequest a quoteCheck eligibility and quote
AetnaRequest a quoteRequest a quoteCheck eligibility and quote
Horizon BCBS NJRequest a quoteRequest a quoteCheck eligibility and quote
Mutual of OmahaRequest a quoteRequest a quoteCheck eligibility and quote
AARP / UnitedHealthcareRequest a quoteRequest a quoteCheck eligibility and quote
HumanaRequest a quoteRequest a quoteCheck eligibility and quote
WellabeRequest a quoteRequest a quoteCheck eligibility and quote
Washington NationalRequest a quoteRequest a quoteCheck eligibility and quote

Plan F is generally available only if you were first eligible for Medicare before January 1, 2020. Confirm each insurer’s current offerings.

Plan G vs. Plan N in New Jersey

Plan G and Plan N offer different balances of premiums and out-of-pocket costs. Here is how they compare on coverage and cost.

Coverage FeaturePlan GPlan N
Part A hospital coinsurance Covered Covered
Part B coinsurance (20%) Covered Covered*
Part A deductible ($1,736 in 2026) Covered Covered
Part B deductible ($283 in 2026) Not covered Not covered
Part B excess charges Covered Not covered
Skilled nursing coinsurance Covered Covered
Foreign travel emergency (subject to policy limits)80% after deductible80% after deductible
Office visit copay$0Up to $20
ER copay (no admission)$0Up to $50

*Plan N covers Part B coinsurance but requires a copay of up to $20 at some doctor visits and up to $50 at emergency rooms (waived if admitted). Part B excess charges are not covered by Plan N, so choose providers who accept Medicare assignment.

Eddie the Eagle — MedicareFAQ mascot
💡 Eddie's Pro Tip

Check your enrollment rights before shopping on price. A lower quote does not guarantee acceptance. Confirm underwriting requirements and an approved start date before replacing your current policy.

When Will You Have to Answer Health Questions?

Outside a protected enrollment window, an insurer may review your health before accepting an application. This is medical underwriting. Applications may ask about diagnoses, treatments, medications, hospital stays, or planned procedures. Questions and look-back periods vary by insurer; answer the actual application accurately.

A review can lead to approval, a different premium where permitted, or a denial. A condition is not automatically disqualifying across every company. Ask about the insurer’s requirements before assuming you can replace your current policy.

Guaranteed issue rights can protect you in specific situations, such as certain involuntary coverage losses or Medicare Advantage trial-right situations. Available plan letters and deadlines depend on the event. Keep termination notices and other supporting records. Medicare explains switching protections here.

Why Medigap Premiums Differ—and Why They Can Rise

Two insurers can charge different amounts for the same standardized benefits. Your quote may reflect your location, age, tobacco use, eligibility for discounts, and the insurer’s rating method. Compare quotes for the same person and effective date; a Newark example is not a quote for every New Jersey ZIP code.

Ask how the policy is priced

Attained-age premiums can rise as you age. Issue-age pricing uses your age when you buy, while community-rated policies do not base premiums on age. Neither issue-age nor community rating guarantees a fixed premium: claims costs and other approved rate changes can still raise the price. Ask which method applies to the specific policy you are considering.

Request the full premium before and after discounts, the discount conditions, and available rate-increase history. Household or payment discounts are not universal. Consider what you would pay if a discount ended, rather than comparing only first-year prices.

The Medicare guide to Medigap costs explains why comparing companies matters. Use a personalized quote for current pricing.

How to Enroll or Switch Without a Coverage Gap

  1. Confirm Medicare and your application window. Check Part A and Part B start dates and any guaranteed issue deadline.
  2. Compare the same plan across insurers. Obtain a written quote and confirm discounts, underwriting, and the requested effective date.
  3. Apply and wait for confirmation. A quote is not an approval. Review the policy, premium, and start date before changing existing coverage.
  4. Coordinate replacement coverage. If leaving Medicare Advantage, confirm a valid election period, Original Medicare’s start date, and any separate Part D coverage. Medigap does not pay Medicare Advantage cost sharing.
  5. Review before canceling the old policy. When switching Medigap policies, use the 30-day free-look period. You generally pay both premiums during the overlap; arrange cancellation after deciding to keep the replacement.

Do not cancel existing coverage based only on an estimated premium. See Medicare’s Medigap buying guide for replacement-policy details.

Where New Jersey Residents Can Get Help

NJ SHIP provides free, impartial Medicare counseling. A counselor can help you check enrollment rights, compare coverage, and review assistance programs. The Department of Banking and Insurance can help with insurer licensing and insurance complaints.

If premiums are difficult to afford, ask about Medicare Savings Programs and prescription-cost assistance before buying another policy. These programs have their own eligibility rules and are not Medigap plans. If you have Medicaid, review how it already works with Medicare before applying for supplemental coverage.

New Jersey Medigap Rules You Should Know

Plan C and Plan F eligibility

These plans are generally limited to people first eligible for Medicare before January 1, 2020. Eligibility is based on when you first qualified for Medicare, not simply when you turned 65.

A policy for each person

A Medigap policy covers one person. Spouses can choose different insurers and plan letters; ask whether a household discount applies.

Check guaranteed issue rights

Certain coverage losses and trial-right situations can provide protection outside your initial enrollment window. Confirm your qualifying event, deadline, and available plan letters before applying.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Medigap include prescription drug coverage?

Policies sold today do not include prescription drug coverage. People with Original Medicare can consider a separate Part D plan and should check its enrollment rules.

Can my spouse use my Medigap policy?

No. Each policy covers one person. Compare individual coverage needs and ask about any household discount rather than assuming both spouses need the same insurer.

Does a lower premium mean fewer standardized benefits?

For the same standardized plan letter, the core benefits are the same across insurers. Compare the actual policy, including whether it is Medicare SELECT or a high-deductible version, before treating quotes as equivalent.

Does fall enrollment guarantee I can switch Medigap?

No. The fall Medicare enrollment period is not a general Medigap guaranteed issue window. An insurer may ask health questions unless an enrollment protection applies.

Will issue-age pricing keep my premium unchanged?

No. Issue-age pricing does not raise the premium simply because you get older, but other rate increases can still apply.

Find the Best Medigap Rate in Your New Jersey ZIP Code

Compare personalized quotes for your plan letter and ZIP code. Ask about enrollment protections, health questions, and discounts before choosing a policy.

(888) 335-8996